Killington's assessors say a copying mistake put the ski trails at Pico on the town's books at $6,000 an acre. The right number, they say, is $45,000. The fix would add about $18 million to the trails' assessed value. The resort company is fighting it.
The town's three elected listers, its property assessors, found the mistake while preparing for a Nov. 5 tax appeal hearing and asked that day for a correction. The listers said $45,000 was the finding of the town's outside appraiser, Tom Lithgow. The $6,000 was recorded when his values were moved into the town's databases and spreadsheets, according to draft minutes of the Board of Civil Authority. That board, made up of the town clerk, the Select Board and the justices of the peace, hears tax appeals. Its minutes call the mistake "a substantial transcription error."
At a hearing a week later, on Nov. 12, Merisa Sherman, one of the listers, said the trails on one Pico parcel, 308.96 acres, should go from $1,853,800 to $13,903,200, according to the draft minutes of that session.
A second parcel, near the Pico summit, has 156 acres of trails. Their value would rise from $936,000 to $7,020,000.
Those are assessed values, not tax bills. The minutes give no figure for what the change would mean for the resort's taxes.
Sherman acknowledged the size of the increase and how late it came, the minutes say. But she told the board that failing to disclose the appraiser's intended value would be, in the minutes' words, "a disservice to other taxpayers."
Thomas Dolan, who presented the appeals for Killington-Pico Ski Resort Partners LLC, the company contesting its assessments at both Pico and Killington, objected to the timing. The $6,000 figure had stood unchanged in the town's property records for several months, he said, and the listers and their appraiser had many chances to review it.
The listers replied that they are responsible for correcting errors found during an appeal. They cited Vermont Supreme Court decisions that they said allow a correction when the taxpayer gets notice and a chance to respond. The decisions are not named in the minutes.
The two sides also disagree about what a ski trail is worth. The listers said their appraiser valued the trails by replacement cost, the same method applied to other properties. Undeveloped land is valued at about $4,000 an acre, Sherman said, and a trail takes clearing, stump removal and grading. The $45,000 covers only the trail itself. Lifts and snowmaking are assessed separately.
Dolan said that Pico opened in 1937 and that most of its trails were built decades ago, so today's construction costs should not be applied to them. The value of ski terrain lies mainly in its lifts and snowmaking, he argued. He said he would accept the original $6,000 an acre and suggested the trails could be valued closer to $4,000, with more of the value assigned to the lifts.
Asked whether trails built decades ago should be marked down for age, the listers said their appraiser believes established trails gain value as they mature and become easier to maintain.
The $45,000 rate is contested at Killington as well. The listers apply it to 46.5 acres of trails on one parcel there, a value of $2,092,500. Substantial portions of Killington sit on land leased from the state, which the listers do not assess.
The lifts and snowmaking are in dispute too. At Pico, the listers recommend $13,139,298 and Dolan proposed $7,069,494. He argued that snowmaking guns, hoses and pumps are already taxed as personal property.
At Killington the listers' figure is $31,311,804 and Dolan's is $20,020,931. Both include $3,325,000 for the resort's Adventure Center, which he does not contest.
The board did not rule on the trails Nov. 12. Bill Vines, the chair, opened the Nov. 12 hearing by reviewing the procedure, and members were reminded that the hearings are not where the board deliberates and that decisions on values come later, the minutes say.
The board was to meet again Monday, Nov. 16. Its agenda called for scheduling site inspections and listed more of the company's parcels for hearing. The minutes list another hearing for Nov. 23 at 9 a.m.
The appeals follow the town's 2026 reappraisal. An owner who disagrees with the board's decision can take it to the state appraiser or to Superior Court.
